‘Horrified’
is a word that falls far short of expressing what I felt when I heard that
Hillary Clinton had lost the US presidential election in 2016, and that a
creature like Donald Trump was going to occupy the Oval Office for the next
four years. Unlike the vast majority of Indians, I have known something about
him since the time he tried to build a casino called the Taj Mahal, you see,
and along the way somehow became a billionaire most of whose businesses had
failed.
‘How
much must even American women voters hate Ms. Clinton?’ ‘What has gone wrong
with their electoral process that this kind of candidate can be put up by
either party and this kind of result produced?’ ‘Has a large part of America
become so stupid, so vulgar, so violent, so embittered with their lot that they
actually think a dirty rich, nearly uneducated (his vocabulary could give many of my current pupils a superiority complex), boorish hustler/con-man/thug
with zero political experience will solve all their problems by waving some
sort of magic wand?’ These were some of the questions that stormed through my
mind when I first heard about it, even as I hunkered down to endure the next
four years, gloomily aware of the sad fact that an American president can not
only mess up his own country’s affairs but still seriously affect the rest of
the world for better or for worse.
And
I have not been disappointed, though I’d have been glad to be. This man has
reduced the image of the US presidency to the dust (compared to him, earlier
fools, duds and manipulators like Dubya Bush now look like sages and saints),
predictably failed to solve any of the problems he had promised to solve
(echoes of New Delhi since 2014?), and nearly demolished the whole edifice of American
democracy as we knew it before losing out on a second term. I guess we should
be glad that he did not precipitate a third world war: but maybe we have only
his instinct for self-preservation at any cost to thank for it.
For
the whole world, he has set new standards of in your face arrogance, shamelessness,
mendacity, self-serving, and total deafness to the most reasonable and valid of
criticisms. Also, about how to live perpetually in an echo chamber, listening
to his own endless self-congratulation* over every fictitious or petty success
(even stooping to highlight Modi’s campaigning for him!) when he is not gorging
on the blind, ignorant adulation of his small but noisy cohort of fanatical,
mostly redneck or wheeler dealer tycoon-supporters. The whole sorry fiasco of a
term ended with a resounding defeat (70 million plus more Americans voted for
Biden!), which, like a pathetic, very badly brought up child throwing tantrums
he refused to concede in the face of the clearest of facts (or harking to ‘facts’
that only he and his ragtag army of devotees seemed to be aware of!), even in
the face of a reprimand from as august an institution as the Supreme Court
(loaded with a Republican majority of judges, too, some even of his own
choosing), simply refusing to quit until very serious anxiety began to mount
whether he would try to thwart the Inauguration of his legitimate successor and
would become the first ever President to be physically arrested and dragged out
of the White House by the police or the military – and maybe thrown forever
into an asylum for the pathologically insane or feeble-minded.
At
last, as many millions like me I’m sure were praying, he went too far. On the
day the Congress was to meet to vote on whether to put the most sacrosanct
stamp of certification on Biden’s election, he egged on a gang of armed goons
calling themselves Republican supporters to besiege Capitol Hill and browbeat
the legislators into stopping the certification process. There was some
violence, some policemen and I think Congressmen were hurt or badly rattled, at
least one person was killed by a police bullet while rioting, and then the vast
majority of lawmakers, Republicans and Democrats alike, closed ranks to condemn
them and ‘(the) injured pride of a selfish man’ (Republican Mitt Romney’s
words) who had provoked them, unbothered about the momentous likely consequences.
The Constitution and democracy were in danger, they decided promptly –
democracy too easily degenerates into mob rule incited by mad demagogues,
they remembered – and that was a far bigger concern than what Donald Trump
wanted. So the rabble was taken care of, and the stamp of certification
granted. In the face of that final ignominy, compounded by a sharp rebuke from
his own vice President Mike Pence, the nut still in the hot seat has said there
will be an orderly transition on January 20, though, like all losers who know
they deserve to lose and cannot bear to face it, he says he still ‘totally
disagrees with the outcome of the election’. Believe it or not, even Modi in a
tweet has condemned this attitude, and twitter has locked his account in
response to his latest barrage of flagrant lying claims of victory. (see this
news article).
Now
we can only hope he at least knows what a promise is, and that it is important
to keep promises. I won’t be surprised if he forgets it completely by tomorrow,
or threatens to hang himself from the White House front balcony instead of
leaving – he is that sort of animal, he’d be thrilled to know that he made one
final front-page-hogging splash before he vanished into richly-deserved
oblivion. Also hope that, since it has been said that Trumpism, that hodgepodge
of mad dreams of the sullen white trash in an economy in slow but terminal
decline, will long outlive Trump, I pray that Biden will be at least halfway
successful in bringing some peace, reconciliation, the spirit of decent
compromise and collective enterprise with common goals back to America.
And for us, half a world away, it is high time to reflect on this sordid drama, and on what lessons we should learn from it before it is too late, in an India that is increasingly Bharat…
[P.S., Jan. 09: *Despite everything that has transpired lately, he has publicly called his own tenure 'the greatest presidential first term in history'. Of course, his followers are probably apes who could never have heard of Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, the Roosevelts or Kennedy, and he talks only to them. He has also firmly demanded in his last days in office that no 'disrespect', meaning arrest or prosecution, should be shown to the vandals and looters who had stormed the Capitol: in his eyes, only they are true patriots. Remember someone saying that patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel?]
6 comments:
Dear Suvroda
After a while, history showed "development" or "developed country" does not mean a bunch of developed people. At least so far US has not blamed any of their neighbours for their internal mess.
At least in US the Republicans, media reprimanded their own president, social media blocked him - I cannot imagine in India that happening. Never ever. Sorry for the pessimism and I acknowledge I may be reading the situation wrongly from far away.
Regards
Tanmoy
Actually you are not, Tanmoy, more's the pity.
Dear Sir,
After my initial shock and dismay at what had transpired at the Capitol subsided, I realised that we were just about twenty-eight years ahead of them. The law enforcers there were a little bit more competent and the insurrectionists (or terrorists), just a little bit less so. I have been following their news since Trump was elected and it’s been difficult for me not to look for similarities and differences between the happenings there and in India.
College campuses in the US tend to lean left, and some of my American colleagues, Democrat supporters, weren’t particularly enamoured of Clinton. They felt she was a hawk, that being an insider, she would perpetuate much of what Obama had done (for instance, bail out banks and leave the average middle class American out to dry, with no job, no house and savings wiped out). At a time when polls indicated that about 70% of Americans were for universal healthcare and free college tuition (which is what Bernie was running on), a lot of Democrat supporters were disillusioned when he was cheated out of the Primaries. They chose to vote independent or not vote at all. Establishment Democrats tend to be socially liberal, but on economic policies, they are often just Republican-light, beholden to their big corporate donors. They didn’t want someone like Bernie, who was raising money from small donors, to make it to the White House because he might actually end up doing what the people wanted! The Republicans simply called him Socialist, Communist, Marxist, and that if he won, the US would become Venezuela.
Along comes Trump, who says some of the same things Bernie had been saying (bring back the jobs, get rid of NAFTA), except with no real substance, but a lot of racism, misogyny and bigotry thrown in, and catchy tags (Build the wall; Drain the swamp; Repeal and replace [Obamacare]; Lock her up), and people lose their minds. No one across the board had given him a shot at winning the primaries leave alone the presidency. They had underestimated how much people really wanted an outsider, how willing people were to be lied to blatantly and just clutch at straws the Don was dispensing, and, of course, how terribly racist a sizeable proportion of the Republican supporters was. He used textbook tropes too. Create an “other” and blame “them” for everything. Create a strawman: a black person kneeling to protest police brutality is somehow insulting the troops and the flag (!!) and, hence, he is antinational.
The most terrifying and disappointing thing was that in spite of four years of Trump, he received 11 million more votes than in 2016! And, in spite of losing to Biden by 7 million votes, he stands second behind him in the total number of votes won by candidates ever. The pandemic might have been the only thing that broke the camel’s back. One must credit black activists, in states like Georgia, who campaigned relentlessly, organising drives to have people register to vote, vote early and so on. It was also disturbing to note that about a hundred and thirty elected officials in Congress objected to the election results during the final ratification, either because they were pandering to their own constituents or because some had presidential ambitions themselves. I’ve read articles in recent times claiming that Trump has gone, but Trumpism might be here to stay, that he has changed the DNA of the party, or that it is just an instance of the move towards the hard right that has been happening the world over.
The role of Facebook and targeted ads aside, that of the media itself cannot be overlooked. There are large parts of America that listen only to Fox News. There are now a couple of news channels that are even loonier than Fox, and to which a lot people subscribe to. They take Trump’s words to heart and repeat them incessantly until they become the truth. Some of the news anchors are already millionaires. I don’t know what they gain by spreading lies, hatred and bigotry. I wonder what their end game is.
(continued)
(continued)
They have many systemic problems: disenfranchising black voters by gerrymandering and voter suppression, the electoral college itself, the fact that the Supreme Court justices are appointed for life and the current one (six conservative to three liberal) will affect generations in a bad way, lobbyists wield way too much power, campaign donations (which are, literally, legalised bribery), the prison system, racism (the number of black people in prison is ridiculously disproportionate) just to name a few. However, their institutions are still very strong (for now). Their freedom of expression is truly as free as it gets (and I am all for it). Comedians, cartoonists, private citizens (i.e., people who don’t necessarily have too much political power) are free to be as critical of a politician (including the President) as they want without fear of physical harm. The courts still function quite well: since the storming of the Capitol, over a hundred people have been identified, caught and charged. We have done almost nothing in the last twenty-eight years, except regressed. Corruption exists at the highest level, often in the form of exploitation of loopholes in existing laws, but it is not endemic at every level of daily life (for example, getting an ID or a driver’s license or having police verification done). There are people speaking out against the President for inciting violence and against his enablers (the elected officials). I am not sure if suspending his Twitter account was the right thing to do (in principle) but it is a big deal in the US (where, again free speech is considered sacred). Our politicians and news anchors get away with way more. There is a grassroots movement taking place in the s-called Progressive faction of the Dems, which gives cause for hope that they might at least be able to bring up “left-wing” economic policies for discussion. They can boast of news outlets like Washington Post and New York Times which, though far from perfect, do provide actual news and not just opinion pieces.
So, scenes of the Storming made me realise that at the core, at the individual level, there might not be too much difference between a crazy person there and here. I am, however, envious that their nightmare might be over, while I see no hope of getting out of ours.
I am afraid this was more of a ramble than a coherent comment: but it is a fraction of what has been on my mind of late.
Sincerely
Nishant.
Many thanks for the very thoughtful comment, Nishant. I have written a longish piece myself, and was waiting to post it on Inauguration Day, but I am now wondering whether you have made much of it unnecessary! :)
Sir
Haha, thank you, sir. I think I forgot to put down certain other points I had in mind. Some day I'll write all of it down systematically. I do look forward to your Inauguration Day-article.
Sincerely
Nishant.
Post a Comment