Explore this blog by clicking on the labels listed along the right-hand sidebar. There are lots of interesting stuff which you won't find on the home page. Also listen to my stories on YouTube. Just type in Suvro Sir or Goppoguchchho.
Seriously curious about me? Click on ' What sort of person am I?'

Monday, August 10, 2026

Kim revisited: a damned good yarn

I think I have mentioned Rudyard Kipling’s magnum opus, the novel Kim, more than once before on this blog. It remains, in my opinion as well as that of millions of other Kipling devotees, the finest and most adoring description of India as she used to be in the early years of the twentieth century, as it traces the travels and travails of the young Irish-Indian orphan boy Kimball O’Hara across the length and breadth of northern India accompanying his chance-found guru Teshoo Lama, and also getting deeply involved in the Great Game of espionage and counter-espionage against the Russians who pose a grave (supposed-) threat to Britain’s Indian empire. It comes to a conclusion when the old lama is convinced that he has found enlightenment. One closes the book with a profound sigh, slowly comes out of a trance, and wishes the story had continued forever. And one keeps going back to it.

Now Stephen Alter has dared to write a sequel to Kim with the title of The Greatest Game (‘being the further adventures of Kimball O’Hara’). The year is 1947, and the story opens in Lahore in March, as India is hurtling towards the ecstasy of Independence cum devastation of Partition, and events are unfolding as rapidly as a river approaching a great waterfall. Kim, who is in his own words, ‘60 or 61’ (he doesn’t care to keep careful track of the years), grizzled and somewhat the worse for wear but still very much engaged with life in the raw, the same life of the chameleon-like street smart and near destitute vagrant that he has always known and loved despite his moments of regret and self-pity, narrowly avoids being murdered and gets drawn into one final adventure: to detect and derail a plot to assassinate some of the top Congress leaders including Nehru, which might quite possibly derail the complex and delicate process of the transfer of power and throw the sub-continent into unimaginable turmoil. To say more about the plot would be to give it away, but here’s a teaser: some Nazi sympathizers in high places are involved. Of course Kim gets the better of the baddies and his private revenge, a couple of medals from the Viceroy himself, as well as a wad of money that will take him wherever he wants to go (but definitely not a fortune with which he can comfortably retire). He vanishes from the scene after one last nostalgic recollection of Zam-zammah, the great bronze cannon that for long adorned the entrance to the Lahore Ajaib ghar (museum), where Kipling began the story.

Oh, I nearly forgot: one of the finest touches in Alter’s story is that the shadowy head of the Imperial Secret Service went under the pseudonym Ulysses, and he had personally designated the motto of the Service as ‘To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield’. Educated readers will not need a note on that: for everyone else there is Google.

 The book ends with some beautiful lines which I am tempted to quote: ‘Now that the Angrez have gone and India has split apart, another chapter will be written in a language all its own. At times like this, I am convinced that I understood the world better when I was a child, rather than as an old man with tangled memories and tortured dreams.’

I intend no disrespect when I say that it is impossible to quite match Kipling’s level of storytelling magic, as Mr. Alter would probably be the first to agree, but I must say that he has done a splendid job of almost catching up. I was especially charmed by two things in this book. One, the way Kim keeps harking back to old memories from his early youth, including his brushes with harsh saver-of-souls missionaries, his stint at St. Xavier’s Lucknow, his mentors including Mahbub Ali the Pathan horse trader from across the border, Creighton sahib and Lurgan sahib who taught him his intricate trade, and the way he accidentally recovered the old lama’s brass begging bowl, a treasure to him indeed. Second, his involvement with two women: Champa, his middle-aged sort of sweetheart who ran a kotha in Lahore, whom he brought safely to Delhi just after the great killings had begun, and his final escapade in tandem with old Anastasia, who had been a close comrade and colleague in years past, who lives in Simla, still harbours a great zest for life despite her creaking joints, and who is now a widowed ranee in retirement. For the rest, my lips are sealed. Read the book; it’s very well worth the expense. Thank you, Stephen Alter – I am going to read some more of your books soon. And thank you Aveek, for lending me the book.

[The Greatest Game, by Stephen Alter, 2025. Aleph Book Company, pp. 243, Rs. 799 hardcover]

Thursday, August 06, 2026

Is the wheel turning?

A book was launched recently at Oxford Book Store, Park Street, in Kolkata. It has been written by Mithu Chakraborti, and it is titled Anatomy of Misery, Part 1: Men's Misery. It was reported in yesterday's edition of The Telegraph, the article ticklishly titled 'Recentring Suffering'. As the writer said, 'I think it is... important to recognise the societal and emotional pressures faced by men... their emotional needs are seldom taken into consideration'. Hear, hear!

 I should like every one of my readers to go through the entire article for themselves (The Telegraph, August 5, 2026, t2, p.5), but I want to quote some lines from it here. The reporter says 'The book, structured as a work of narrative non-fiction and popular psychology (whatever that means - SC), comprises twelve interconnected stories. In these, a multitude of men find themselves facing various conflicts owing to the stereotypical expectations and  burdens inflicted upon them by a ... culture that does not acknowledge men's need for emotional support and expression. Themes of men's loneliness, emotional isolation, domestic abuse (so at last some people are  beginning to admit that men are abused too, ha ha ha!-SC), the pressures of being a provider and the personal costs incurred by men in a society that expects them to be silent are the focus of these stories'. Oindrila Dutt, arts curator and one of the guests at the book launch, added, 'This book reminds us that it is high time for us to extend equal consideration for men's and women's miseries in society (good to hear that such equality, it is now being admitted, was not accorded for a long time! - SC). It is a crucial reminder that we need to address the pressures faced by men who have been betrayed (so now we can openly say that we are often betrayed too, huh? - SC), but sadly think that they are at fault.' 

Well, AT LAST!  Countless generations of men, many of them nice, good, responsible, hardworking, honorable men, have worked, suffered and died in silence because they had always been told that men do not, must not, admit and lament and ask for amelioration of their suffering (I keep remembering Harihar Ray in Pather Panchali, along with many other such characters real and fictional). My generation suffered a double whammy - the rise of a particularly sick, strident, one-eyed, obsessive 'feminism' that screamed at us all our lives that it is only women's 'right' (for want of a better word) to suffer and whine about their suffering, and to keep on pillorizing us men for all of it being our fault, no matter how many of us tried, however hard, to make life good and happy for them: if some men are awful, every one of us must bear the guilt and go through life hanging our heads in shame, while being completely shouted down and blithely ignored if we sometimes mumbled 'Well, we suffer too, you know, and it is not always our fault; maybe we deserve a little attention and sympathy and consideration sometimes, too?'

But let that be. One human lifespan is too small against the backdrop of history to notice much significant change anyway, and maybe the wheel is turning the right way already before my eyes? I wrote not too long ago about a woman who is vigorously running a Men's Rights Association, and here is another woman who has written a book like this. Maybe I shall see some change for the better before I die? Maybe some women will again begin to say that men are equally human too, and women can be bad humans too, or at least have a lot of faults and failings which they should do something about? Maybe, God willing, some more women will even begin to think, like Ms. Chakraborti, that we men have been getting a raw deal for a nastily long time, and say so in public for all to hear?