Explore this blog by clicking on the labels listed along the right-hand sidebar. There are lots of interesting stuff which you won't find on the home page
Seriously curious about me? Click on ' What sort of person am I?'

Monday, April 24, 2023

World English Day

Yesterday, April 23, I learnt very recently from a Google Doodle made for the occasion, was the UN World English Language Day. It was chosen - not inappropriately, I believe - because it was the date on which William Shakespeare was born and also supposedly died. The UN decided in 2010 to observe the day every year as such. Their website article claims that today one in four human beings uses English in one way or the other. Both Shakespeare and Thomas Carlyle would have smiled: I think it was the latter who said towards the end of the 18th century that Shakespeare was more valuable to 'us' (the British) than the empire, and so it has turned out to be. Via Shakespeare, the very best of what it once meant to be English has been spread around the world. But certainly both Shakespeare and Carlyle would have been astounded to see how much and how diversely the language has changed since their times, and what people are doing with it these days. Although, come to think of it, as one of the supremely great creative artists of all time and therefore an inveterate experimenter and pusher of boundaries, Shakespeare would probably have been more amused than shocked.

English and Shakespeare have fed me all my life. Materially, aesthetically, intellectually and spiritually. My debt to them is immeasurable, but I thank them every single day.

However, in this context, as an observant and thinking man, I would like to put on record a few ideas.

1. If you learn English for a purely utilitarian purpose - to wit, passing school exams and getting a job - you are bound to learn it poorly, which you will gradually realize with dismay as the years roll by. If it is worth learning, it is worth learning well.

2. Don't be taken in by fancy labels and tall claims: many schools, coaching institutes and internet mentors don't know much English at all, and while they are eager to fleece you, they will teach you little, and what is worse, they will teach you a lot of things that are just plain wrong. Not knowing is much better than 'knowing' wrong things. 

3. You don't have to disrespect and neglect your native tongue in order to learn good English. Indeed, I lament the great disservice that has been done by (West-) Bengalis to their vernacular over the last fifty years in their haste to become slavish imitators of the sahibs: very few Bengalis can read, write or speak fluent and correct Bangla today, and that has rarely been compensated by a really good grasp of the English language. From Rammohun Roy to Satyajit, they have all shown that you can be equally a master of both Bangla and English.

4. English grants you access to all the great books of the world, ancient and modern, spiritual, artistic, philosophical, scientific and technical, as no single other language does, or is ever likely to. So learn English well in order that the doors of the world's knowledge can be opened widest for you.

5. Finally, do not let the latrine slush of social media push you down into the gutter of what used once to be called pidgin, or 'coolie English'. I have no intention of being called elitist, or a snob, or a 'grammar Nazi', but if you imagine that knowledge of language needs no discipline of the mind, no hard work, no sense of standards, you have lost sight of both culture and civilization. Remember, 'I does' is plain wrong, writing 'Sir was' when you mean 'Sir is' is not a small mistake, 'He stopped to look' and 'he stopped looking' mean exactly opposite things, saying a natural sight is 'sick' when you mean lovely is weird, brilliant engineering is not 'insane', everything in this world is not 'great' or 'amazing', nor is anyone cool because s/he is hot. It only means your brains have fallen out, and you have joined the ranks of the great (mentally-) unwashed. No glory in that, though there might be safety in numbers, of the kind that is appropriate only for quadrupeds.

Happy English learning to all.

7 comments:

Sunandini Mukherjee said...

Dear Sir,
Thank you for writing (yet again) what you have been saying for years. Also, I thank you for developing my love for the English language through a variety of seemingly non-academic things. I fondly remember the word games you made us play after the syllabus had been completed, verses from As You Like It that you sometimes set to tune (and sang), and the vast number of books, movies and interviews you continue to direct us to.
I was teaching 'tenses' to a batch of first year engineering students when I heard one of them utter "Ei ma'am ta awesome poray kintu". I could hear you in my mind when I asked them if 1) ma'am was an object that could be counted as 'ta', and 2) if they thought that my lecture was as awe inspiring as their first sight of the Himalayas, or seeing one's child for the first time. Only years will tell if my words could make even one of them think.
Regards,
Sunandini

Suvro Chatterjee said...

Haha, Sunandini, I wish you luck! And thank you for commenting.

Sunandini Mukherjee said...

Thank you, Sir!

Tanmoy said...

Dear Suvro da

Thank you for writing this piece. This takes me back to our discussions in the school library about the importance of learning a language properly. Further to what you already mentioned about "social media", kids these days hardly even know how to write, thanks to keyboard. While I wish to remain optimistic about future but it is challenging.

Regards
Tanmoy

Suvro Chatterjee said...

I try to stay hopeful too, Tanmoy, and even at this late stage I can see occasional bright spots to cheer me up. However, I shall note here that schools worldwide have been guilty for a long time of not making a strong, sustained effort to teach the young how to write decently. In every generation there will only be a microscopic few who write really well, but basic literacy of the kind I demand before I can call anyone civilized should not have been given the short shrift. Someday we shall all pay for it, maybe when good writing - despite ChatGPT! - will have become a rare and very highly paid skill!

Aveek Mukherjee said...

Dear Sir,

Thanks for this thought-provoking piece. I hope you find many takers for this post.

Every time I point out absolutely ungrammatical errors, people usually come up with 'Oi ek e holo'. These days, I respond with 'Does Physics allow us to take such a liberty with its laws and Chemistry with its reactions?'

They are bad English, that's all. And no, I won't 'kindly adjust' to that!

Regards,

Aveek


Saikat Chakraborty said...

Dear Sir,

Amen to all that you wrote and have been saying all these years!

This language has opened doors for me that I did not know existed. I am grateful to you for playing a significant part in showing me some of these doors.

Yours sincerely,
Saikat.